Should I Buy a New or Used Car?

May 18, 2022

Buying a car in 2022 is hard. Deciding if you should buy a new or used vehicle is even more difficult. Used car prices have increased unlike any other time in history, and the new car shortage means you may need to wait months to take delivery of an ordered vehicle.

While in years past the answer to “should I buy a new or used car” was more obvious, today it is trickier to answer. Let’s break down the pros and cons of buying new and used and what our recommendation is here at CarEdge.

Let’s dive in.

The case for buying a new car

You might feel a little crazy if you buy a new car in 2022 … Just a few years ago, the idea of paying MSRP for a new car was unheard of. Today, paying MSRP is a deal.

Car dealers nationwide have been adding additional dealer markups (ADMs) to their vehicles. For many brands, the average transaction price is well above the original vehicle’s MSRP.

If new cars are selling for more than MSRP, how could it possibly make sense to buy one in this market? The case is quite simple; if you can find a dealership who will sell you a vehicle at MSRP (and in some cases below it), then you should jump on it.

kia markups
The 5 Most Marked-Up Cars in 2022

It is widely expected that automakers will significantly increase their MSRPs for the 2023 model year. We have already seen many manufacturers increase MSRPs during the 2022 model year.

Pair this with the reality that used vehicles are appreciating assets, and you can begin to see why purchasing a 2022 new vehicle at MSRP is a relative “bargain”. New vehicles come with the full manufacturer warranty and typically are eligible for special financing through the manufacturer’s lending arm. Used vehicles are selling for the same price as new vehicles and they don’t have those benefits. For this reason, if you can find a dealership selling a vehicle at MSRP we recommend you strongly consider it.

To find a dealership selling at MSRP we encourage you to search our community-driven dealership reviews. Research over 1,700 reviews that have been submitted by other community members.

Get the most when you sell your car.

Compare and choose multiple offers in minutes:

The case for buying a used car

What is the rationale for buying a used car in 2022? Price. If you cannot afford a new vehicle (which is understandable since the average transaction price in April 2022 was $42,000), then older used cars become your only option.

Sadly, 8-16 year old used cars have seen the most rapid price appreciation so far in 2022. This is because many people are looking for under $20,000 price-point vehicles and their only options are older used cars.

If you are looking for a vehicle in this price range it is critically important that you do your due diligence before purchasing it. Pre-purchase inspections are non-negotiable in today’s market. We have heard many horror stories of “junk” cars being sold to consumers, and the best way to protect yourself from that happening is to get an inspection done before you purchase.

Not all used cars have appreciated equally. Gas guzzler vehicles have depreciated in 2022, while compact and subcompact sedans have appreciated. The trade off here is obvious; save money by spending less on gas guzzler vehicle, but spend more on fuel, or spend more on a more fuel efficient smaller car and save on fuel.

Buying a used car in today’s market is incredibly challenging.

Should I buy a new or used car — why we recommend new

If you’re reading this blog post, the odds are high that you already knew it is a tough time to buy a new or used car. Unlike in years past where the financially prudent decision was to buy a used car, we think it makes more sense to buy a new vehicle in 2022. While that’s easier said than done, we think it will pay off in the long run.

If you cannot afford a new vehicle, then finding a used vehicle that passes a pre-purchase inspection is your best bet.

As always we recommend going through Deal School before you contact any seller, and please don’t hesitate to post on the free community forum to get help. It’s a challenging market, but we’re here to help.

COVERAGE YOU CAN TRUST

CarEdge Extended Warranty

Peace of mind without the markup.
Flexible terms & pricing.
Coverage details

 

Discover the right insurance for you

Compare different providers with no spam phone calls:

Call us 855.786.1144

M-F: 8AM – 9PM EST
Sat: 10AM – 6PM EST

Save more with CarEdge+

CarEdge+ Membership pays for itself for all things auto.

Unlimited access to CarEdge car buying tools, our team of Auto Experts, savings on maintenance, and repairs, and more.

Join CarEdge+
Learn More

Join CarEdge for Free

Get instant access to members-only resources.

We'll email you updates
Or, we can text you
Hidden
Subscribe to receive:

Consultations

$50 per 15-minute live session

Chat with a CarEdge Auto Expert to make sure you’re negotiating a fair deal.

  • Connect live on video or call.
  • Get live advice on any part of the buying process.
  • Ask us anything about your journey.

CarEdge Coach

$99 one-time

Partner with a dedicated coach to help you save thousands on your car deal.

  • Your coach will guide and assist through your journey.
  • Access to all premium resources, like Deal School 3.0, email templates and market pricing!
  • Learn how to buy a car with leverage and confidence.

CarEdge Concierge

$999 one-time

A dedicated concierge to handle all aspects of your car deal for you.

  • Concierge handles all communication with the dealer.
  • We negotiate the selling price, trade in, financing, warranties and insurance.
  • We listen, do the leg work and secure your deal.

Auto insights. Right in your inbox.

We'll email you updates
Or, we can text you
Hidden
Subscribe to receive:

Get the latest trends and money-saving strategies, once a week.

We'll email you updates
Or, we can text you
Hidden
Subscribe to receive:

Related articles

2 Comments

  1. Gonzalez, AK

    I think that there should be an article or video titled “Don’t Sell Your Used Car – yet!”. New Car and Used Car prices are untenable in this geopolitical world dependent environment. My 2 ICE are Chevy Sonics. One has 65,000 miles and is an automatic (2016); my other on has 106,500 miles and it is a 6 speed tranny (a 2013 model). Both have the same Turbo boosted engine. I get much better milage from my 2013 than my 2016. Gas is $4.49 a gallon today. I look forward to the day when I can buy an EV but the prices have to go much lower and the range( plus) charging time have to be comparable to my ICEs. Great article Zach!

    Reply
  2. Daniel McMenamin

    Ordered a ford maverick last October, and put down a $500 deposit. Ford did acknowledge the order.
    my question is how do I enforce the agreed-upon price with the dealer? I only want to pay the price I agreed to.
    Advice, suggestions help.

    Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Share This