The Best and Worst States to Buy a Car in 2024: Navigating Taxes, Fees, and Inventory

What vehicle are you interested in?

Last updated Jun 7, 2024

When it comes to purchasing a new or used car, the state you’re in can make a significant difference in terms of taxes, fees, and available inventory. We’ll take a look at the best and worst states to buy a car in 2024, focusing on factors like sales tax, insurance costs, documentation fees, and overall car supply. Let’s dive in and see how your state stacks up.

Best States to Buy a Car

First, let’s explore the states that offer the most advantages when it comes to car buying. States like Alaska, Montana, Oregon, Delaware, and New Hampshire stand out due to their lack of statewide sales tax, as well as generally low unexpected fees. Iowa is also noteworthy for its affordable insurance rates, averaging less than $720 annually.

These are the most and least expensive cars to insure.

Several other states have low statewide sales tax rates. These states have a sales tax between 2% and 5%: Alabama (2%), Colorado (2.9%), Hawaii (4%), Louisiana (4%), Missouri (4.23%), New Mexico (4%), New York (4%), North Carolina (3%), Oklahoma (3.25%), South Dakota (4%), and Virginia (4.15%). Depending on the price of the car you’re looking at, these lower sales tax rates could save you several hundred dollars or more.

Dealerships charge a documentation fee, or “doc fee,” to cover the cost of preparing and filing a sales contract. Many states don’t regulate doc fees, and the amount varies from state to state. These states have the lowest doc fees in 2023, and as a result, are better states to buy a car in: Minnesota ($75), Arkansas ($110), Oregon ($115), South Dakota ($115), Iowa ($135), Texas ($150), Washington ($150), Indiana ($150). California is also on the list with a very low average doc fee of $85, but the high sales tax and low supply of new cars keeps it far off of the list of best states to buy a car in. 

Car Dealer Doc Fee by State – 2024

Worst States to Buy a Car

Florida is one of the worst states to buy a new car in

Now, let’s take a look at the states you might want to avoid when purchasing a vehicle. Florida, California, and several southern states have the lowest supply of new cars, making it difficult to find the right vehicle. High-cost states like Alabama, Arizona, California, and Tennessee can also be problematic due to additional fees that can average around $2,000.

Documentation fees can be particularly high in Alabama, Virginia, and North Carolina, with fees ranging from $485 to $599. Florida stands out as one of the worst states for new car purchases, with no cap on doc fees (averaging $995) and limited new car inventory.

In 2024, these are the states with the lowest supply of new cars, according to data from CarEdge:

  • Georgia
  • Florida
  • California
  • New Jersey
  • Texas

However, Florida’s abundant used car market can make it a better choice for used car buyers, thanks to the state’s older population and the steady influx of used vehicles. On the other hand, flood cars are a much bigger risk in Florida’s used car market.

Free Car Buying Help Is Here

Car buying cheat sheet

Ready to outsmart the dealerships? Download your 100% free car buying cheat sheets today. From negotiating a deal to leasing a car the smart way, it’s all available for instant download. Get your cheat sheets today!

3 Comments

  1. Ken C

    I’m in Florida. If I buy a car out of state will that dealer withhold the sales tax because I am taking the car to FL where I have to pay tax anyway? How does one register a car if bought in a different state?

    Reply
  2. Jim O'Neill

    You only pay the tax where your titling its a miss conception that your are charged in both states. Atleast that the way it is in illinois . You pay the sales tax to your state unless you state tax recipical

    Reply
  3. Dave

    I would add that Oklahoma actually ends up being about 4.5%-4.6% tax rate on the purchase price REGARDLESS if you trade a vehicle or not. It is based 100% on the full actual purchase price of the vehicle period (not what you paid after trade any trade). i.e. $46,000 negotiated price x 4.6% = $2,070 in taxes. Get $40,000 in value on that deal. Taxes are STILL $2,070. Super frustrating to not get credit for your trade.

    Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

NEWSLETTER

The latest insights
right in your inbox

Get the latest car trends and money-saving strategies, once a week.

By signing up, you agree to CarEdge's Privacy Policy and Terms & Conditions.

Share This