Here’s How Much Consumer Reports’ Top Cars for 2024 Actually Cost

What vehicle are you interested in?

Last updated Feb 28, 2024

Discovering a vehicle that ticks all the boxes for performance, comfort, and style can transform your daily commute into a journey you look forward to. This year, Consumer Reports has done the heavy lifting for us, meticulously testing and evaluating most of the 260 new car models on the market in 2024. Here at CarEdge, we’re big fans of CR. For each of the Consumer Reports Top Picks for 2024, we’ve used CarEdge Data to reveal the true selling price and current market supply, showing you market dynamics in real time. We hope you find this bit of a twist useful in your Car Search.

Fresh off the digital presses, these are the 10 best cars, trucks, and SUVs for 2024, as ranked by Consumer Reports

The Best Subcompact SUV

Subaru Crosstrek

Subaru Crosstrek ratings

MSRP: $25,195 – $32,195

Average Selling Price: $31,620

Current Market Supply: 83 days of supply (learn more)

Consumer Reports Overall Score: 87/100

NHTSA Safety Rating: 5-Star Rating

The 2024 Crosstrek features significant updates including enhanced engines, a modernized infotainment system, and an advanced EyeSight safety suite, alongside the best fuel economy for a non-hybrid AWD SUV at 29 mpg. While the base 2.0-liter engine may feel underpowered, the optional 2.5-liter variant offers improved speed, noise control, and overall driving satisfaction. Here’s Consumer Reports’ complete review.

See Crosstrek listings with the power of local market data

The Best Hybrid Car

Toyota Prius

Consumer Reports Prius ratings

MSRP: $27,950 – $36,365

Average Selling Price: $35,137

Current Market Supply: 31 days of supply (learn more)

Consumer Reports Overall Score: 80/100

NHTSA Safety Rating: Not recently rated

While the 2024 Toyota Prius offers a more engaging driving experience and a cooler look, it sacrifices some comfort and visibility compared to its predecessor. The Prius Prime variant adds versatility with 39 electric-only miles and a gas-only efficiency of 43 mpg, enhancing the appeal of this distinctive and striking vehicle. It’s not the Prius of yesterday! Here’s Consumer Reports’ complete review.

See Prius listings with the power of local market data

The Best Compact SUV

Subaru Forester

2024 Subaru Forester ratings

MSRP: $27,095 – $37,395

Average Selling Price: $35,287

Current Market Supply: 109 days of supply (learn more)

Consumer Reports Overall Score: 88/100

NHTSA Safety Rating: 5-Star Rating

In its final year before a redesign, the 2024 Forester remains a Consumer Reports Top Pick for the 11th time, thanks to its practical boxy design that enhances interior space and visibility. It’s easy access, spacious and comfortable interior, along with ample cargo space, stand out in the small SUV category. Combining one of the best ride qualities in its class with responsive and secure handling, the Forester continues to be a highly recommended, well-rounded vehicle. Check out the complete review from Consumer Reports.

See Forester listings with the power of local market data

The Best Small Car

Mazda 3

2024 Mazda3 reviews

MSRP: $24,170 – $36,650

Average Selling Price: $30,002

Current Market Supply: 124 days of supply (learn more)

Consumer Reports Overall Score: 78/100

NHTSA Safety Rating: 5-Star Rating

The Mazda3, available as both sedan and hatchback, redefines the small, affordable car segment with its enjoyable driving dynamics, nimble handling, and capable powertrains. Mazda offers two engine options: a base engine with 191 hp and an optional 227-hp turbocharged upgrade. Its premium feel on higher trims positions it above its mainstream competitors, providing all-wheel drive and standard Blind Spot Warning (BSW) and Rear Cross Traffic Warning (RCTW) for 2024. Here’s CR’s complete review.

See Mazda 3 listings with the power of local market data

The Best Midsized Car

Toyota Camry Hybrid

2024 Camry reviews

MSRP: $26,420 – $36,845

Average Selling Price: $32,315

Current Market Supply: 41 days of supply (learn more)

Consumer Reports Overall Score: 93/100

NHTSA Safety Rating: 5-Star Rating

The Camry Hybrid excels in delivering fuel efficiency and comfort at a budget-friendly price point. It achieves an outstanding 47 mpg overall in fuel economy tests, with a remarkable 53 mpg on the highway, complemented by a 610-mile range per tank, making it ideal for both daily commutes and long road trips. Next year, the Camry becomes a Hybrid in all trim levels. See CR’s complete review. 

See Toyota Camry Hybrid listings with the power of local market data

The Best Small Pickup Truck

Ford Maverick

2024 Ford Maverick reviews

MSRP: $23,815 – $34,855

Average Selling Price: $32,794

Current Market Supply: 35 days of supply (learn more)

Consumer Reports Overall Score: 78/100

NHTSA Safety Rating: 4-Star Rating

The Maverick sets itself apart in the truck segment with its easy maneuverability, notable fuel economy, and affordability. Its crew cab offers a spacious and practical interior with ample legroom and headroom, complemented by user-friendly controls and well-placed storage options. The 191-hp hybrid version shines for its exceptional fuel efficiency and enhanced refinement, making the Maverick a high-value, functional choice for those wanting a truck without the difficulty parking a full-size model, not to mention affording gas. CR members can see the complete review.

See Ford Maverick listings with the power of local market data

The Best Plug-In Hybrid SUV

Toyota RAV4 Prime

2024 RAV4 ratings

MSRP: 43,690 – $47,560

Average Selling Price: $46,890

Current Market Supply: 34 days of supply (learn more)

Consumer Reports Overall Score: 89/100

NHTSA Safety Rating: 5-Star Rating

The RAV4 Prime, a plug-in hybrid variant of the best-selling SUV in America, is so popular that it’s hard to find one that’s not already taken. It offers 42 miles of electric-only range, allowing for significant gas savings, especially in urban driving. The RAV4 Prime maintains a commendable 34 mpg overall fuel efficiency once the battery is depleted. If you’re not ready to go full-EV, this plug-in hybrid is a great alternative. 

But keep in mind that you could buy a fast-charging EV like the Hyundai IONIQ 5, Kia EV6, or Tesla Model 3 for the same price. Check out CR’s complete review of the RAV4 Prime.

See RAV4 Prime listings with the power of local market data

The Best Midsized SUV

Toyota Highlander Hybrid

Toyota Highlander reviews

MSRP: $39,120 – $53,125

Average Selling Price: $48,586

Current Market Supply: 34 days of supply (learn more)

Consumer Reports Overall Score: 85/100

NHTSA Safety Rating: 5-Star Rating

The Highlander stands out as a comfortable midsize SUV with an impressive suite of active safety features, and a strong predicted reliability. Its 243-hp hybrid powertrain leads in fuel efficiency for three-row SUVs, achieving 35 mpg overall and 41 mpg on the highway in tests, complemented by a 590-mile range on a full tank. The hybrid model’s modest $1,500 premium over the gas-only version promises swift returns through fuel savings. CR members can check out this complete review.

See Highlander listings with the power of local market data

The Best Luxury SUV

BMW X5

best luxury SUV 2024

MSRP: $65,200 – $122,300

Average Selling Price: $80,107

Current Market Supply: 60 days of supply (learn more)

Consumer Reports Overall Score: 92/100

NHTSA Safety Rating: Not rated recently

The X5 offers a luxury experience, and that’s what you should expect at this price. It features a balanced suspension that ensures a supple ride and composed handling, suitable for curvy roads, while the turbo-six engine provides quick acceleration. The standout is the plug-in hybrid version, which combines a turbo inline-six with an electric motor and a battery that enables 39 miles of all-electric range. Gone are the days of PHEVs getting just 20 miles of electric range! Here’s CR’s complete review.

See BMW X5 listings with the power of local market data

The Best Electric Vehicle

Tesla Model Y

Tesla Model Y Consumer Reports

MSRP: $42,990 – $52,490

Average Selling Price: N/A

Current Market Supply: N/A (learn more)

Consumer Reports Overall Score: 72/100

NHTSA Safety Rating: 5-Star Rating

The Model Y has been the best-selling electric vehicle in America and Europe for quite some time. With its SUV-like body, the Model Y offers more passenger and cargo space than its sedan counterpart, the Model 3. With long range and a widespread, easy to use Supercharger network, the Model Y is the perfect choice for first time EV buyers. Additionally, its capability for over-the-air updates means that the Model Y’s features can be continuously enhanced, making an already impressive vehicle even better with time. See CR’s complete review of the Model Y.

See used Tesla Model Y listings with the power of local market data, or configure your new Model Y at Tesla.com

Free Car Buying Help Is Here!

Car buying cheat sheet

Ready to outsmart the dealerships? Download your 100% free car buying cheat sheets today. From negotiating a deal to leasing a car the smart way, it’s all available for instant download. Get your cheat sheets today!

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

OUR NEWSLETTER

The latest insights.
Right in your inbox.

Get the latest car trends and money-saving strategies, once a week.

OUR NEWSLETTER

The latest insights.
Right in your inbox.

Get the latest car trends and money-saving strategies, once a week.

Streamline your car buying experience with a concierge

We take care of the entire buying process with the dealership, ensuring you get the vehicle you want at a fair price.

Share This