Best Subaru Dealerships in New York, Ranked by CarEdge Data
Key Takeaways
- Top 10 Subaru dealers in New York, ranked using verified out-the-door quotes — not Google star ratings.
- Brewster Subaru (Brewster) is the highest-graded Subaru dealer in New York.
- Johnstons Subaru (Middletown) carries the main watch-out — add-ons appear on 57% of verified quotes, averaging $343 — the highest rate here.
- Get an OTD quote in writing before you visit any dealer. CarEdge tracks real prices, not advertised ones.
This is the CarEdge Dealer Transparency Index ranking for Subaru dealers across New York. We grade dealers using verified out-the-door quotes — real PDFs, emails, and signed deals — not Google star ratings.
We graded every Subaru dealer in New York with enough verified out-the-door quotes to score with confidence. If you’re shopping a specific metro, jump to the city-by-city rankings below for a tighter local shortlist.
About the CarEdge Dealer Transparency Index
Most dealer rankings come from Google star ratings and Yelp reviews — easy to game, impossible to verify. The CarEdge Dealer Transparency Index is different. We score every dealer using verified out-the-door quotes: real PDFs, emails, and screenshots from actual transactions.
Each dealer’s transparency score (out of 100) is weighted across four dimensions:
- Fee Transparency (30%) — Is the doc fee reasonable compared to the state average?
- Add-on Behavior (30%) — How often does the dealer bundle add-ons, and at what cost?
- Price Accuracy (30%) — Does the listing price match the actual OTD price?
- Data Quality (10%) — More verified quotes mean higher confidence in the grade.
Grades: A (90–100), B (80–89), C (70–79), D (60–69), F (below 60).
Top 10 Subaru Dealers in New York
Ranked by CarEdge transparency score, highest to lowest. Each dealer profile links to the full review with verified out-the-door quotes.
#1 — Brewster Subaru
Grade: A · Score: 100/100 · Brewster, NY
Brewster Subaru is the top-graded Subaru dealer in New York by verified data — A grade, 100/100, based on 19 verified OTD quotes.
- Doc fee: $269 — well above the NY average of $208
- Add-ons: None detected in verified quotes
- Listing accuracy: 0.7% below the advertised listing
- Verified quotes: 19
See full review & verified quotes →
#2 — Subaru White Plains
Grade: A · Score: 100/100 · Elmsford, NY
Subaru White Plains adds zero dealer add-ons in any verified quote — rare for an A-grade Subaru dealer.
- Doc fee: $175 — below the NY average of $208
- Add-ons: None detected in verified quotes
- Listing accuracy: Quoted price matches the advertised listing
- Verified quotes: 10
See full review & verified quotes →
#3 — Curry Subaru
Grade: A · Score: 100/100 · Cortlandt, NY
Curry Subaru’s $105 doc fee comes in well below the NY average of $208 — money that stays in your pocket at signing.
- Doc fee: $105 — well below the NY average of $208
- Add-ons: None detected in verified quotes
- Listing accuracy: 1.2% above the advertised listing
- Verified quotes: 5
See full review & verified quotes →
#4 — Mid-Hudson Subaru
Grade: A · Score: 97/100 · Wappingers Falls, NY
Mid-Hudson Subaru quotes prices within 0.2% of the advertised listing — one of the cleanest pricing patterns on this list.
- Doc fee: $153 — well below the NY average of $208
- Add-ons: 13% of quotes, avg $49
- Listing accuracy: Quoted price matches the advertised listing
- Verified quotes: 8
See full review & verified quotes →
#5 — Island Subaru
Grade: A · Score: 96/100 · Staten Island, NY
Add-ons showed on only 20% of Island Subaru’s verified quotes — restrained by segment standards.
- Doc fee: $175 — below the NY average of $208
- Add-ons: 20% of quotes, avg $139
- Listing accuracy: 1.9% above the advertised listing
- Verified quotes: 5
See full review & verified quotes →
#6 — Fox Subaru
Grade: A · Score: 95/100 · Auburn, NY
Fox Subaru holds the A grade across 24 verified OTD quotes — a substantial sample size.
- Doc fee: $280 — well above the NY average of $208
- Add-ons: 17% of quotes, avg $114
- Listing accuracy: 0.9% above the advertised listing
- Verified quotes: 24
See full review & verified quotes →
#7 — Grand Prix Subaru
Grade: A · Score: 95/100 · Hicksville, NY
Grand Prix Subaru keeps add-ons on just 11% of verified quotes — light for an A-grade dealer.
- Doc fee: $117 — well below the NY average of $208
- Add-ons: 11% of quotes, avg $111
- Listing accuracy: 2.9% above the advertised listing
- Verified quotes: 9
See full review & verified quotes →
#8 — Five Star Subaru
Grade: A · Score: 90/100 · Oneonta, NY
Five Star Subaru quoted prices 12.9% below the advertised listing — the kind of discount that rewards getting the OTD in writing.
- Doc fee: $0 — well below the NY average of $208
- Add-ons: None detected in verified quotes
- Listing accuracy: 12.9% below the advertised listing
- Verified quotes: 4
See full review & verified quotes →
#9 — Johnstons Subaru
Grade: B · Score: 88/100 · Middletown, NY
Johnstons Subaru earns a solid B on verified data — solid fundamentals. The one watch-out: add-ons show on 57% of quotes (avg $343).
- Doc fee: $240 — above the NY average of $208
- Add-ons: 57% of quotes, avg $343
- Listing accuracy: 1.8% above the advertised listing
- Verified quotes: 7
See full review & verified quotes →
#10 — Colonial Subaru
Grade: B · Score: 81/100 · Poughkeepsie, NY
Add-ons showed on only 21% of Colonial Subaru’s verified quotes — restrained by segment standards.
- Doc fee: $699 — well above the NY average of $208
- Add-ons: 21% of quotes, avg $43
- Listing accuracy: 1.3% above the advertised listing
- Verified quotes: 14
See full review & verified quotes →
New York Subaru Dealer Rankings at a Glance
| # | Dealer | City | Grade | Score | Doc Fee | Add-Ons | Quotes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Brewster Subaru | Brewster | A | 100 | $269 | $0 | 19 |
| 2 | Subaru White Plains | Elmsford | A | 100 | $175 | $0 | 10 |
| 3 | Curry Subaru | Cortlandt | A | 100 | $105 | $0 | 5 |
| 4 | Mid-Hudson Subaru | Wappingers Falls | A | 97 | $153 | $49 | 8 |
| 5 | Island Subaru | Staten Island | A | 96 | $175 | $139 | 5 |
| 6 | Fox Subaru | Auburn | A | 95 | $280 | $114 | 24 |
| 7 | Grand Prix Subaru | Hicksville | A | 95 | $117 | $111 | 9 |
| 8 | Five Star Subaru | Oneonta | A | 90 | $0 | $0 | 4 |
| 9 | Johnstons Subaru | Middletown | B | 88 | $240 | $343 | 7 |
| 10 | Colonial Subaru | Poughkeepsie | B | 81 | $699 | $43 | 14 |
How to Use This Data When You Shop
- Get an OTD quote in writing before you visit. Any dealer can send a worksheet by email — if they won’t, that’s a red flag.
- Ask for a quote with zero add-ons. Everything in the F&I office is optional. Say “please remove all dealer add-ons” and see what the price does.
- Anchor to the OTD, not the listing. Dealers with a gap between advertised price and final OTD aren’t being straight with you. Don’t negotiate off the listing number.
- Compare three dealers minimum. Even within the same metro, doc fees, add-on policies, and listing accuracy vary widely. Use this ranking as your shortlist.
Rankings are generated from the CarEdge Dealer Transparency Index, a public methodology that scores dealers on verified out-the-door quotes — not Google star ratings or paid placements. Data updated quarterly. Last updated: Q3 2026.
Sponsored by Insurify
Are you overpaying for car insurance?
Compare rates from top carriers in under 5 minutes. CarEdge users save an average of $996/year on auto insurance.
*Disclosure: CarEdge may earn a commission when you compare insurance quotes through our partner, Insurify. This does not influence our editorial content.*
