Dealer Reviews

Best Used Car Dealers in New York City, Ranked by CarEdge Data

ZS
Zach Shefska
Published Updated 17 min read

This is the CarEdge Dealer Transparency Index ranking of used car dealers in the New York City metro. It covers independent used lots and the used departments of new-car dealers, graded on out-the-door quotes from the past year, not star ratings.

74 dealers in New York City have enough used-car quotes from the past year to grade, one of the top 20 of them independent. Below are the top 20.

Last updated November 17, 2026. CarEdge refreshes these rankings daily as new verified out-the-door quotes come in.

What is the best used car dealer in New York City?

The best used car dealer in New York City by out-the-door quotes from the past year is All American Subaru in Old Bridge (Subaru dealer, used department, Old Bridge): A grade, 100/100, 21 used-car quotes from the past year, with $699 in dealer fees on used cars, under the NJ median of $799.

Close behind:

  1. Ace Auto Haus (independent, Hazlet), A grade, 100/100, 8 used-car quotes from the past year, with $795 in dealer fees on used cars, under the NJ median of $799.
  2. South Shore Nissan (Nissan, Amityville), A grade, 100/100, 5 used-car quotes from the past year, with 5 used-car quotes from the past year behind its numbers.

Best for:

Among the A and B dealers ranked on this page, on used-car quotes from the past year only.

Full ranking, used-car dealer fees and quoted add-ons for every graded dealer are below.

CarEdge Certified Dealers in New York City

All American Subaru in Old Bridge, Ace Auto Haus, South Shore Nissan, and All American Ford in Old Bridge are the CarEdge Certified dealers in New York City. CarEdge Certified is a tier above a letter grade. Certified dealers hold an A grade on the CarEdge Dealer Transparency Index and guarantee four things on every deal:

  • All-in out-the-door price up front
  • No surprise add-ons
  • Fast, real answers
  • An honest, no-pressure experience

CarEdge verifies the guarantee with ongoing AI mystery shops, and a dealer that slips below an A grade loses the badge. Certification is earned from data, never bought.

All American Subaru in Old Bridge: CarEdge Certified Subaru dealer in Old Bridge

All American Subaru in Old Bridge in Old Bridge, NJ is CarEdge Certified. It holds an A grade on the CarEdge Dealer Transparency Index (100/100 across 98 quotes from the past year) and guarantees an all-in out-the-door price up front, no surprise add-ons, fast, real answers, and an honest, no-pressure experience on every deal. CarEdge last mystery shopped All American Subaru in Old Bridge on November 15, 2026.

  • Dealer fees: $699 — below the NJ median of $799

See All American Subaru in Old Bridge’s grade and verified quotes →

Ace Auto Haus: CarEdge Certified independent dealer in Hazlet

Ace Auto Haus in Hazlet, NJ is CarEdge Certified. It holds an A grade on the CarEdge Dealer Transparency Index (100/100 across 9 quotes from the past year) and guarantees an all-in out-the-door price up front, no surprise add-ons, fast, real answers, and an honest, no-pressure experience on every deal. CarEdge last mystery shopped Ace Auto Haus on September 18, 2026.

  • Dealer fees: $795 — below the NJ median of $799

See Ace Auto Haus’s grade and verified quotes →

South Shore Nissan: CarEdge Certified Nissan dealer in Amityville

South Shore Nissan in Amityville, NY is CarEdge Certified. It holds an A grade on the CarEdge Dealer Transparency Index (100/100 across 5 quotes from the past year) and guarantees an all-in out-the-door price up front, no surprise add-ons, fast, real answers, and an honest, no-pressure experience on every deal. CarEdge last mystery shopped South Shore Nissan on November 16, 2026.

  • Dealer fees: $175 — at the NY median

See South Shore Nissan’s grade and verified quotes →

All American Ford in Old Bridge: CarEdge Certified Ford dealer in Old Bridge

All American Ford in Old Bridge in Old Bridge, NJ is CarEdge Certified. It holds an A grade on the CarEdge Dealer Transparency Index (98/100 across 42 quotes from the past year) and guarantees an all-in out-the-door price up front, no surprise add-ons, fast, real answers, and an honest, no-pressure experience on every deal. CarEdge last mystery shopped All American Ford in Old Bridge on November 15, 2026.

  • Dealer fees: $699 — below the NJ median of $799

See All American Ford in Old Bridge’s grade and verified quotes →

See every CarEdge Certified dealer →

Top 20 Used Car Dealers in New York City

Ranked by CarEdge transparency score, highest to lowest. Used-car figures come from each dealer’s used and CPO quotes from the past year.

#1 — All American Subaru in Old Bridge

Subaru dealer, used department · Grade: A · Score: 100/100 · CarEdge Certified · Old Bridge, NJ

All American Subaru in Old Bridge is the highest-graded used car dealer in New York City on quotes from the past year, with $699 in dealer fees on used cars, under the NJ median of $799.

  • Used-car quotes, past year: 21
  • Dealer fees on used cars: $699 — below the NJ median of $799
  • CarEdge Certified: Yes. Guarantee verified by ongoing CarEdge AI mystery shops. What CarEdge Certified means

See full review & verified quotes →

#2 — Ace Auto Haus

Independent used car dealer · Grade: A · Score: 100/100 · CarEdge Certified · Hazlet, NJ

Ace Auto Haus ranks #2 among used car dealers in New York City on quotes from the past year, with $795 in dealer fees on used cars, under the NJ median of $799.

  • Used-car quotes, past year: 8
  • Dealer fees on used cars: $795 — below the NJ median of $799
  • CarEdge Certified: Yes. Guarantee verified by ongoing CarEdge AI mystery shops. What CarEdge Certified means

See full review & verified quotes →

#3 — South Shore Nissan

Nissan dealer, used department · Grade: A · Score: 100/100 · CarEdge Certified · Amityville, NY

South Shore Nissan ranks #3 among used car dealers in New York City on quotes from the past year, with 5 used-car quotes from the past year behind its numbers.

  • Used-car quotes, past year: 5
  • Dealer fees on used cars: $175 — at the NY median
  • CarEdge Certified: Yes. Guarantee verified by ongoing CarEdge AI mystery shops. What CarEdge Certified means

See full review & verified quotes →

#4 — Freehold Subaru

Subaru dealer, used department · Grade: A · Score: 100/100 · Freehold, NJ

Freehold Subaru ranks #4 among used car dealers in New York City on quotes from the past year, with no quoted add-ons in any of its used-car quotes from the past year.

  • Used-car quotes, past year: 4
  • Dealer fees on used cars: $699 — below the NJ median of $799
  • Quoted add-ons on used cars: None in used-car quotes from the past year

See full review & verified quotes →

#5 — Hamilton Mazda

Mazda dealer, used department · Grade: A · Score: 100/100 · Hamilton Township, NJ

Hamilton Mazda ranks #5 among used car dealers in New York City on quotes from the past year, with no quoted add-ons in any of its used-car quotes from the past year.

  • Used-car quotes, past year: 5
  • Dealer fees on used cars: $599 — below the NJ median of $799
  • Quoted add-ons on used cars: None in used-car quotes from the past year

See full review & verified quotes →

#6 — Kia Of West Nyack

Kia dealer, used department · Grade: A · Score: 100/100 · West Nyack, NY

Kia Of West Nyack ranks #6 among used car dealers in New York City on quotes from the past year, with no quoted add-ons in any of its used-car quotes from the past year.

  • Used-car quotes, past year: 8
  • Dealer fees on used cars: $175 — at the NY median
  • Quoted add-ons on used cars: None in used-car quotes from the past year

See full review & verified quotes →

#7 — Subaru White Plains

Subaru dealer, used department · Grade: A · Score: 100/100 · Elmsford, NY

Subaru White Plains ranks #7 among used car dealers in New York City on quotes from the past year, with no quoted add-ons in any of its used-car quotes from the past year.

  • Used-car quotes, past year: 9
  • Dealer fees on used cars: $175 — at the NY median
  • Quoted add-ons on used cars: None in used-car quotes from the past year

See full review & verified quotes →

#8 — Island Mazda

Mazda dealer, used department · Grade: A · Score: 100/100 · Staten Island, NY

Island Mazda ranks #8 among used car dealers in New York City on quotes from the past year, with no quoted add-ons in any of its used-car quotes from the past year.

  • Used-car quotes, past year: 8
  • Dealer fees on used cars: $175 — at the NY median
  • Quoted add-ons on used cars: None in used-car quotes from the past year

See full review & verified quotes →

#9 — Paul Conte Cadillac

Cadillac dealer, used department · Grade: A · Score: 100/100 · Freeport, NY

Paul Conte Cadillac ranks #9 among used car dealers in New York City on quotes from the past year, with no quoted add-ons in any of its used-car quotes from the past year.

  • Used-car quotes, past year: 4
  • Dealer fees on used cars: $175 — at the NY median
  • Quoted add-ons on used cars: None in used-car quotes from the past year

See full review & verified quotes →

#10 — Rallye BMW

BMW dealer, used department · Grade: A · Score: 100/100 · Westbury, NY

Rallye BMW ranks #10 among used car dealers in New York City on quotes from the past year, with no quoted add-ons in any of its used-car quotes from the past year.

  • Used-car quotes, past year: 5
  • Dealer fees on used cars: $175 — at the NY median
  • Quoted add-ons on used cars: None in used-car quotes from the past year

See full review & verified quotes →

#11 — Freehold Dodge & RAM

Dodge dealer, used department · Grade: A · Score: 100/100 · Freehold, NJ

Freehold Dodge & RAM ranks #11 among used car dealers in New York City on quotes from the past year, with no quoted add-ons in any of its used-car quotes from the past year.

  • Used-car quotes, past year: 7
  • Dealer fees on used cars: $699 — below the NJ median of $799
  • Quoted add-ons on used cars: None in used-car quotes from the past year

See full review & verified quotes →

#12 — Lia Toyota Of Rockland

Toyota dealer, used department · Grade: A · Score: 100/100 · Blauvelt, NY

Lia Toyota Of Rockland ranks #12 among used car dealers in New York City on quotes from the past year, with no quoted add-ons in any of its used-car quotes from the past year.

  • Used-car quotes, past year: 5
  • Dealer fees on used cars: $175 — at the NY median
  • Quoted add-ons on used cars: None in used-car quotes from the past year

See full review & verified quotes →

#13 — Subaru Of Englewood

Subaru dealer, used department · Grade: A · Score: 99/100 · Englewood, NJ

Subaru Of Englewood ranks #13 among used car dealers in New York City on quotes from the past year, with no quoted add-ons in any of its used-car quotes from the past year.

  • Used-car quotes, past year: 7
  • Dealer fees on used cars: $589 — below the NJ median of $799
  • Quoted add-ons on used cars: None in used-car quotes from the past year

See full review & verified quotes →

#14 — Mazda Of Valley Stream

Mazda dealer, used department · Grade: A · Score: 99/100 · Valley Stream, NY

Mazda Of Valley Stream ranks #14 among used car dealers in New York City on quotes from the past year, with no quoted add-ons in any of its used-car quotes from the past year.

  • Used-car quotes, past year: 9
  • Dealer fees on used cars: $175 — at the NY median
  • Quoted add-ons on used cars: None in used-car quotes from the past year

See full review & verified quotes →

#15 — Haldeman Subaru

Subaru dealer, used department · Grade: A · Score: 99/100 · Robbinsville Township, NJ

Haldeman Subaru ranks #15 among used car dealers in New York City on quotes from the past year, with no quoted add-ons in any of its used-car quotes from the past year.

  • Used-car quotes, past year: 5
  • Dealer fees on used cars: $598 — below the NJ median of $799
  • Quoted add-ons on used cars: None in used-car quotes from the past year

See full review & verified quotes →

#16 — Mercedes-Benz Of Nanuet

Mercedes-Benz dealer, used department · Grade: A · Score: 99/100 · Nanuet, NY

Mercedes-Benz Of Nanuet ranks #16 among used car dealers in New York City on quotes from the past year, with no quoted add-ons in any of its used-car quotes from the past year.

  • Used-car quotes, past year: 5
  • Dealer fees on used cars: $175 — at the NY median
  • Quoted add-ons on used cars: None in used-car quotes from the past year

See full review & verified quotes →

#17 — All American Ford in Old Bridge

Ford dealer, used department · Grade: A · Score: 98/100 · CarEdge Certified · Old Bridge, NJ

All American Ford in Old Bridge ranks #17 among used car dealers in New York City on quotes from the past year, with $699 in dealer fees on used cars, under the NJ median of $799.

  • Used-car quotes, past year: 11
  • Dealer fees on used cars: $699 — below the NJ median of $799
  • CarEdge Certified: Yes. Guarantee verified by ongoing CarEdge AI mystery shops. What CarEdge Certified means

See full review & verified quotes →

#18 — Ray Catena Lexus Of Larchmont

Lexus dealer, used department · Grade: A · Score: 98/100 · Larchmont, NY

Ray Catena Lexus Of Larchmont ranks #18 among used car dealers in New York City on quotes from the past year, with no quoted add-ons in any of its used-car quotes from the past year.

  • Used-car quotes, past year: 8
  • Dealer fees on used cars: $175 — at the NY median
  • Quoted add-ons on used cars: None in used-car quotes from the past year

See full review & verified quotes →

#19 — Tasca Central Ave Hyundai

Hyundai dealer, used department · Grade: A · Score: 98/100 · Hartsdale, NY

Tasca Central Ave Hyundai ranks #19 among used car dealers in New York City on quotes from the past year, with no quoted add-ons in any of its used-car quotes from the past year.

  • Used-car quotes, past year: 4
  • Dealer fees on used cars: $176 — above the NY median of $175
  • Quoted add-ons on used cars: None in used-car quotes from the past year

See full review & verified quotes →

#20 — Dover Dodge Route 15 Used Car Center

Dodge dealer, used department · Grade: A · Score: 98/100 · Wharton, NJ

Dover Dodge Route 15 Used Car Center ranks #20 among used car dealers in New York City on quotes from the past year, with no quoted add-ons in any of its used-car quotes from the past year.

  • Used-car quotes, past year: 4
  • Dealer fees on used cars: $498 — below the NJ median of $799
  • Quoted add-ons on used cars: None in used-car quotes from the past year

See full review & verified quotes →

How CarEdge Ranks Used Car Dealers

Every dealer here has at least four out-the-door quotes from the past year for used or certified pre-owned vehicles: real PDFs, emails and screenshots from actual shoppers, not star ratings. The ranking and grade are the dealer’s published CarEdge Dealer Transparency Index grade, which weights Fee Transparency (30%), Add-on Behavior (30%), Price Accuracy (30%) and Data Quality (10%) across its quotes from the past year, newer quotes counting more. Every dealer fee and quoted add-on figure on this page comes from its used-car quotes from the past year only. Read the methodology →

Grades: A (90–100), B (80–89), C (70–79), D (60–69), F (below 60).

New York City Used Car Dealer Rankings at a Glance

#DealerTypeCityGradeScoreUsed Dealer FeesUsed Quoted Add-onsUsed Quotes, Past Year
1All American Subaru in Old Bridge (CarEdge Certified)SubaruOld BridgeA100$699—21
2Ace Auto Haus (CarEdge Certified)independentHazletA100$795—8
3South Shore Nissan (CarEdge Certified)NissanAmityvilleA100$175—5
4Freehold SubaruSubaruFreeholdA100$699None4
5Hamilton MazdaMazdaHamilton TownshipA100$599None5
6Kia Of West NyackKiaWest NyackA100$175None8
7Subaru White PlainsSubaruElmsfordA100$175None9
8Island MazdaMazdaStaten IslandA100$175None8
9Paul Conte CadillacCadillacFreeportA100$175None4
10Rallye BMWBMWWestburyA100$175None5
11Freehold Dodge & RAMDodgeFreeholdA100$699None7
12Lia Toyota Of RocklandToyotaBlauveltA100$175None5
13Subaru Of EnglewoodSubaruEnglewoodA99$589None7
14Mazda Of Valley StreamMazdaValley StreamA99$175None9
15Haldeman SubaruSubaruRobbinsville TownshipA99$598None5
16Mercedes-Benz Of NanuetMercedes-BenzNanuetA99$175None5
17All American Ford in Old Bridge (CarEdge Certified)FordOld BridgeA98$699—11
18Ray Catena Lexus Of LarchmontLexusLarchmontA98$175None8
19Tasca Central Ave HyundaiHyundaiHartsdaleA98$176None4
20Dover Dodge Route 15 Used Car CenterDodgeWhartonA98$498None4

Shopping new? CarEdge also ranks every brand’s dealers in New York City: see the best car dealerships in New York City.

How to Buy a Used Car Without Surprises

  1. Get an itemized out-the-door quote in writing before you visit. If a dealer won’t send one, keep shopping.
  2. Ask what fees apply to used cars. Reconditioning, prep and certification fees often show up only on used vehicles.
  3. Ask for all dealer add-ons removed. Window tint, nitrogen and protection packages are optional.
  4. Get the vehicle history report and an independent inspection. A fair price on a car with problems is not a good deal.
  5. Compare at least three dealers. Used-car dealer fees in the same metro can differ by hundreds of dollars.

Rankings are generated from the CarEdge Dealer Transparency Index, a public methodology that scores dealers on out-the-door quotes from the past year, not Google star ratings or paid placements. CarEdge refreshes the rankings daily as new quotes come in.

Share

Sponsored by Insurify

Are you overpaying for car insurance?

Compare rates from top carriers in under 5 minutes. CarEdge users save an average of $996/year on auto insurance.

*Disclosure: CarEdge may earn a commission when you compare insurance quotes through our partner, Insurify. This does not influence our editorial content.*

Free Resource

Get our free car buying cheat sheets & guides

7 PDFs to help you negotiate smarter and spend less at the dealership.

Get FREE Cheat Sheets

Stay on top of car news

No spam, only useful & relevant information and recommendations.

By signing up, you agree to CarEdge's Privacy Policy and Terms and Conditions.

Related Guides