Toyota Insurance Rates

Toyota Insurance Rates

The average cost of car insurance for Toyota models is about $2,390 per year.

This is $505 better than other popular brands. Our car insurance comparison studies assume a 40 year old good driver with full coverage and good credit, that drives around 13,000 miles per year. They also assume a single-car policy on a brand-new vehicle, and won't reflect any multi-car discounts. Many things can contribute to the actual rates. These variables include vehicle, age, location, mileage, credit score, driving record and more. Below you will find a chart that illustrates some of these differences. The tables further down show how these factors impact Toyota insurance rates.

Good Driver and Credit
Recent At-Fault Accident
Poor Credit Rating

Toyota insurance rates will vary significantly between providers for the same coverage. If you've been with your current insurance company for more than a few years, you should get new quotes to make sure you're not overpaying. Try our Competitive Quote Tool or the form below to get free quotes to lower your insurance costs. Advertising Disclosure


The cost to insure a Toyota model will differ significantly by the age of the driver. Younger drivers cost more to insure because they are much more likely to be at fault in an accident. That probability decreases dramatically by the time they turn 25 and so do the premiums. In fact, insurance cost by age continues to decline until after age 60, but the increases after are modest.

Are car insurance rates based on credit score?

Credit plays a big role in premiums in most states. The under 25 crowd is far more likely to have very little credit established. The best way to mitigate this would be to join their family's multi-vehicle policy. Their rates will become more affordable as they age up and maintain a decent driving record. They can also build their credit at the same time. While paying car insurance doesn't improve credit on its own, using a credit card to so monthly can. As long as it's paid in full every billing cycle, of course. This is also an easy way to accumulate points on a rewards credit card as it's an expense required for every driver.

Insurance costs by age vary between brands based on resale values and safety ratings. If you're not set on a Toyota, then see our insurance analysis and rankings for other makes and models here.

Toyota Insurance Rates by Age*

Age Good Driver Recent Accident Poor Credit
17 $8,095 $11,886 $13,905
18 $7,544 $11,077 $12,959
19 $6,667 $9,789 $11,452
20 $5,813 $8,536 $9,986
21 $4,875 $7,158 $8,374
22 $4,748 $6,971 $8,156
23 $4,154 $6,100 $7,136
24 $3,946 $5,795 $6,779
25 $3,406 $5,001 $5,850
30 $2,653 $3,896 $4,558
35 $2,485 $3,649 $4,269
40 $2,390 $3,509 $4,105
45 $2,326 $3,415 $3,995
55 $2,133 $3,132 $3,664
65 $2,225 $3,267 $3,822
75 $2,808 $4,123 $4,823

Toyota auto insurance premiums can cost a lot more or less depending on where you live. Rates are more expensive in Michigan because they mandate much higher coverage levels. California, Hawaii and Massachusetts don't allow providers to adjust rates based on credit. These figures also do not include the potential discounts on a multi-vehicle policy. Those can provide significant savings to a household full of drivers. The table below is a breakdown of how these factors can affect Toyota models by state.


Average Toyota Insurance Rates by State*

State Good Driver Recent Accident Poor Credit
Georgia $2,769 $4,141 $4,175
Wyoming $1,964 $2,750 $2,928
Wisconsin $2,104 $3,285 $3,747
West Virginia $2,111 $3,022 $3,787
Washington $2,098 $2,847 $3,400
Virginia $1,585 $2,433 $2,385
Vermont $1,682 $2,591 $2,738
Utah $2,185 $3,062 $4,213
Texas $2,569 $3,711 $4,616
Tennessee $2,551 $3,755 $5,001
South Dakota $2,169 $3,125 $3,606
South Carolina $2,417 $3,350 $4,624
Rhode Island $3,560 $5,222 $5,880
Pennsylvania $2,132 $3,130 $3,663
Oregon $2,531 $3,396 $4,056
Oklahoma $2,782 $3,983 $4,485
Ohio $1,742 $2,687 $2,755
North Dakota $1,954 $2,969 $3,511
North Carolina $1,428 $2,453 $1,749
New York $2,303 $2,900 $4,841
New Mexico $2,486 $3,698 $3,839
New Jersey $2,435 $3,820 $4,998
New Hampshire $2,210 $3,494 $4,417
Nevada $3,176 $4,712 $4,977
Nebraska $1,926 $2,848 $3,094
Montana $2,278 $3,179 $3,700
Missouri $2,241 $3,204 $4,209
Mississippi $2,378 $3,392 $3,414
Minnesota $1,970 $2,627 $3,699
Michigan $4,786 $7,293 $11,503
Massachusetts $1,983 $3,460 $1,983
Maryland $2,473 $3,599 $3,998
Maine $1,528 $2,112 $3,119
Louisiana $4,041 $6,109 $6,624
Kentucky $3,148 $4,621 $5,457
Kansas $2,178 $3,169 $3,706
Iowa $1,637 $2,245 $2,640
Indiana $2,067 $3,159 $3,545
Illinois $2,012 $3,041 $3,467
Idaho $1,922 $2,548 $3,097
Hawaii $1,106 $1,502 $1,106
Florida $3,397 $4,699 $6,124
Delaware $2,853 $3,802 $4,883
Connecticut $3,446 $5,344 $6,784
Colorado $2,697 $3,775 $4,789
California $2,890 $5,111 $2,890
Arkansas $2,596 $4,079 $4,491
Arizona $2,368 $3,423 $5,043
Alaska $2,094 $2,903 $2,822
Alabama $2,532 $3,677 $4,681

Related Articles

GAP Insurance Explained: Not Every Car Buyer Needs It

Car Insurance Rates Soared 24%

Car Ownership Costs Beyond the Price Tag: What to Expect