Dealer Reviews

Best Car Dealership Groups, Ranked by CarEdge Data

ZS
Zach Shefska
Published Updated 25 min read

This is the CarEdge Dealer Transparency Index ranking of car dealership groups: the companies that own many dealerships, from national chains like AutoNation and Lithia to regional groups. Each group’s grade rolls up its stores’ verified out-the-door quotes, not star ratings. CarEdge grades 699 groups; the 187 below each have at least 5 stores with four or more quotes from the past year.

Last updated November 16, 2026. CarEdge refreshes these rankings daily as new verified out-the-door quotes come in.

The Best Car Dealership Groups

The best car dealership group by verified out-the-door price data is Safford Automotive Group: grade A (99/100) across 23 graded stores and 176 quotes from the past year.

Close behind:

  1. Mullinax Ford, grade A (99/100) across 10 graded stores and 163 quotes from the past year.
  2. Fields Auto Group, grade A (99/100) across 33 graded stores and 126 quotes from the past year.

Among the largest groups, Asbury Automotive Group ranks highest: grade A (95/100) across 153 graded stores and 1,481 quotes from the past year.

The Largest Dealership Groups Compared

The 10 groups with the most graded stores, side by side. Click a group for every store and its grade.

GroupGradeScoreGraded StoresStatesAvg Dealer FeesQuoted Add-ons
Lithia MotorsA9027925$57934%
AutoNationA9126120$68440%
Asbury Automotive GroupA9515315$72920%
Group 1 AutomotiveA9413217$52318%
Penske Automotive GroupA9311421$47725%
Sonic AutomotiveA9210717$53548%
Berkshire Hathaway AutomotiveA9110010$51948%
Morgan Auto GroupC71721$2,01926%
Ed Napleton Automotive GroupA95717$54119%
Ken Garff Automotive GroupA91619$41636%

Top 10 Dealership Groups

Ranked by CarEdge transparency score, highest to lowest.

#1 — Safford Automotive Group

Grade: A · Score: 99/100 · 23 graded stores in 2 states

Safford Automotive Group earns grade A (99/100) across 23 graded stores and 176 quotes from the past year. Its stores average $967 in dealer fees, with quoted add-ons on 7% of quotes from the past year. Its highest-graded store is Safford Subaru Manassas in Manassas, VA (100/100).

See every Safford Automotive Group store and its grade →

#2 — Mullinax Ford

Grade: A · Score: 99/100 · 10 graded stores in 3 states · 1 CarEdge Certified

Mullinax Ford earns grade A (99/100) across 10 graded stores and 163 quotes from the past year. Its stores show quoted add-ons on 2% of quotes from the past year. Its highest-graded store is Hyundai Montgomery in Montgomery, AL (100/100).

See every Mullinax Ford store and its grade →

#3 — Fields Auto Group

Grade: A · Score: 99/100 · 33 graded stores in 5 states

Fields Auto Group earns grade A (99/100) across 33 graded stores and 126 quotes from the past year. Its stores average $795 in dealer fees, with quoted add-ons on 2% of quotes from the past year. Its highest-graded store is Fields BMW South Orlando in Orlando, FL (100/100).

See every Fields Auto Group store and its grade →

#4 — J.C. Lewis Motor Company

Grade: A · Score: 99/100 · 6 graded stores in 1 state · 6 CarEdge Certified

J.C. Lewis Motor Company earns grade A (99/100) across 6 graded stores and 123 quotes from the past year. Its stores average $911 in dealer fees, with quoted add-ons on 3% of quotes from the past year. Its highest-graded store is J.C. Lewis Ford Of Statesboro in Statesboro, GA (100/100).

See every J.C. Lewis Motor Company store and its grade →

#5 — Patterson Autos

Grade: A · Score: 99/100 · 5 graded stores in 1 state · 3 CarEdge Certified

Patterson Autos earns grade A (99/100) across 5 graded stores and 105 quotes from the past year. Its stores average $105 in dealer fees, with no quoted add-ons in quotes from the past year. Its highest-graded store is Tustin Hyundai in Tustin, CA (100/100).

See every Patterson Autos store and its grade →

#6 — Ferman Automotive Group

Grade: A · Score: 99/100 · 11 graded stores in 1 state

Ferman Automotive Group earns grade A (99/100) across 11 graded stores and 103 quotes from the past year. Its stores average $1,326 in dealer fees, with quoted add-ons on 14% of quotes from the past year. Its highest-graded store is Ferman Chevrolet Of Brandon in Tampa, FL (100/100).

See every Ferman Automotive Group store and its grade →

#7 — Huffines Auto Dealerships

Grade: A · Score: 99/100 · 10 graded stores in 1 state

Huffines Auto Dealerships earns grade A (99/100) across 10 graded stores and 96 quotes from the past year. Its stores average $257 in dealer fees, with no quoted add-ons in quotes from the past year. Its highest-graded store is Huffines Kia Mckinney in McKinney, TX (100/100).

See every Huffines Auto Dealerships store and its grade →

#8 — The Gerald Auto Group

Grade: A · Score: 99/100 · 14 graded stores in 1 state

The Gerald Auto Group earns grade A (99/100) across 14 graded stores and 95 quotes from the past year. Its stores average $404 in dealer fees, with quoted add-ons on 25% of quotes from the past year. Its highest-graded store is Gerald Hyundai in North Aurora, IL (100/100).

See every store in The Gerald Auto Group and its grade →

#9 — Preston Automotive Group

Grade: A · Score: 99/100 · 16 graded stores in 3 states

Preston Automotive Group earns grade A (99/100) across 16 graded stores and 56 quotes from the past year. Its stores average $778 in dealer fees, with quoted add-ons on 2% of quotes from the past year. Its highest-graded store is Preston Toyota Of Easton in Easton, MD (100/100).

See every Preston Automotive Group store and its grade →

#10 — The Premier Collection

Grade: A · Score: 99/100 · 7 graded stores in 2 states

The Premier Collection earns grade A (99/100) across 7 graded stores and 51 quotes from the past year. Its stores average $175 in dealer fees, with no quoted add-ons in quotes from the past year. Its highest-graded store is Subaru White Plains in Elmsford, NY (100/100).

See every store in The Premier Collection and its grade →

How CarEdge Ranks Dealership Groups

CarEdge grades each store on verified out-the-door quotes: real PDFs, emails and screenshots from shoppers. Each store’s transparency score weights Fee Transparency (30%), Add-on Behavior (30%), Price Accuracy (30%) and Data Quality (10%), using quotes from the past year only, with newer quotes counting more; a store with no quote in the past year has no grade. A group’s score rolls up its graded stores, and its grade follows the same bands: A (90–100), B (80–89), C (70–79), D (60–69), F (below 60). Dealer fees partly reflect state rules, so a group concentrated in low-fee states will show a lower average. Read the methodology →

All 187 Ranked Dealership Groups

#GroupGradeScoreGraded StoresStatesAvg Dealer FeesQuoted Add-ons
1Safford Automotive GroupA99232$9677%
2Mullinax FordA99103—2%
3Fields Auto GroupA99335$7952%
4J.C. Lewis Motor CompanyA9961$9113%
5Patterson AutosA9951$105None
6Ferman Automotive GroupA99111$1,32614%
7Huffines Auto DealershipsA99101$257None
8The Gerald Auto GroupA99141$40425%
9Preston Automotive GroupA99163$7782%
10The Premier CollectionA9972$175None
11Ourisman Automotive GroupA98222$8608%
12Swickard Auto GroupA98365$19333%
13Castle Automotive GroupA98182$3916%
14Ciocca DealershipsA98373$5654%
15Fox MotorsA98281$28819%
16Passport Auto GroupA9892$842None
17McCombs AutomotiveA9881$2438%
18New Country Motor Car GroupA98206$71711%
19Carter Myers AutomotiveA98214$83511%
20Executive Auto GroupA98121$67729%
21Ourisman Automotive of VirginiaA9891$9651%
22Joseph Auto GroupA98152$4068%
23Rairdon Automotive GroupA98121$20112%
24Tom Wood Auto GroupA98112$30320%
25Chicagoland Auto GroupA9871$3959%
26Paramount AutomotiveA9891$9193%
27David Wilson Automotive GroupA97163$34823%
28Mileone AutogroupA97476$7994%
29Holman Automotive GroupA97489$73551%
30Jeff Wyler Automotive FamilyA97353$44310%
31Nucar Automotive GroupA97226$5836%
32Great Lakes Auto GroupA9794$39111%
33Russ Darrow GroupA97131$53116%
34Schomp Automotive GroupA97133$554%
35Jim Shorkey Auto GroupA97183$6773%
36International Autos GroupA97113$43016%
37Berman Auto GroupA9781$4106%
38Ray Catena Motor CarA97112$469None
39Page Auto GroupA9771$80811%
40Luther Automotive GroupA96397$34016%
41Fitzgerald Auto MallsA96213$8055%
42Flow AutomotiveA96352$77918%
43Pohanka Automotive GroupA96173$7963%
44Boucher GroupA96231$53311%
45Ourisman Auto GroupA96124$8977%
46Sierra Auto GroupA9692$1919%
47Mcgovern Automotive GroupA96284$58318%
48Baxter Auto GroupA96164$1218%
49DARCARS Automotive GroupA96136$83522%
50LaFontaine Automotive GroupA96301$28118%
51Bergey’s Auto DealershipsA96131$51118%
52Fusz Automotive NetworkA96164$5163%
53Muller Auto GroupA9662$38316%
54Hoffman Auto GroupA96102$82433%
55Bakhtiari Auto GroupA9681$10418%
56Hertrich Family of Auto DealershipsA96183$83713%
57Bommarito Automotive GroupA96111$616None
58Asbury Automotive GroupA9515315$72920%
59Ed Napleton Automotive GroupA95717$54119%
60Faulkner Automotive GroupA95281$53515%
61Phil Long DealershipsA95142$69722%
62LAcarGuy Dealership GroupA95111$16312%
63Kenwood Dealer GroupA95141$43718%
64Tasca Automotive GroupA95329$43216%
65Morrie’s Automotive GroupA95235$40017%
66Sloane Automotive GroupA9571$54023%
67Browning Auto GroupA9551$11223%
68Group 1 AutomotiveA9413217$52318%
69Hudson Auto GroupA94567$81716%
70Sheehy Auto StoresA94292$99512%
71Hiley Automotive GroupA94152$36620%
72Key Auto GroupA94206$7838%
73Keffer Auto GroupA94142$89223%
74Brandon Steven MotorsA94112$15619%
75CZ GroupA9461$1,30310%
76Superior Automotive GroupA94134$5686%
77Island Auto GroupA94102$28917%
78O’Brien Auto GroupA94112$21222%
79Balise Motor SalesA94183$7587%
80Fletcher Jones CaliforniaA94122$31011%
81Penske Automotive GroupA9311421$47725%
82Findlay Automotive GroupA93355$48530%
83Germain Automotive GroupA93286$67523%
84Kendall Auto GroupA93395$32926%
85Del Grande Dealer GroupA93161$13123%
86Ken Ganley Automotive GroupA93334$62017%
87Jim Ellis Automotive GroupA93231$82427%
88Serra AutomotiveA93378$46419%
89Norm Reeves Auto GroupA93153$28322%
90Zeigler Auto GroupA93294$38024%
91Piazza Auto GroupA93253$55231%
92Johnson AutomotiveA93103$92625%
93Rick Case Automotive GroupA93102$1,01219%
94Preston Auto GroupA93102$5622%
95Sonic AutomotiveA9210717$53548%
96Gee Automotive Cos.A92385$33720%
97Ed Morse Automotive GroupA92348$84427%
98Premier AutomotiveA92309$35819%
99Stivers AutomotiveA92106$87621%
100Gilchrist AutomotiveA92192$41721%
101Holler Classic Automotive GroupA92162$1,3789%
102Cavender Auto FamilyA92152$31629%
103Gunn Automotive GroupA9271$32714%
104Southern Maryland Auto GroupA92111$94325%
105Car Pros Automotive GroupA9261$8937%
106#1 Cochran Automotive GroupA92232$5968%
107Hanania Automotive GroupA92142$1,43815%
108McCarthy Auto GroupA92112$68920%
109Step One Automotive GroupA92101$98738%
110Cooper Auto GroupA9281$7853%
111Bob Moore Auto GroupA92131$69218%
112Lupient Automotive GroupA9282$50120%
113AutoNationA9126120$68440%
114Berkshire Hathaway AutomotiveA9110010$51948%
115Ken Garff Automotive GroupA91619$41636%
116Keating Auto GroupA91282$28733%
117Sewell Automotive CompaniesA91231$25830%
118Mac Haik Auto GroupA91182$35420%
119Murgado Automotive GroupA91255$87917%
120World Car Auto GroupA91121$23037%
121Butler Auto GroupA91123$1,04618%
122Young Automotive GroupA91183$43241%
123Sam Pack Automotive GroupA9172$36524%
124Barnes Crossing Auto GroupA91104$64530%
125Lithia MotorsA9027925$57934%
126Gettel AutomotiveA90201$1,52514%
127Phil Smith Automotive GroupA90122$1,12532%
128Crossroads Auto GroupA90153$94335%
129Corwin Automotive GroupA90179$76933%
130Bob Rohrman Auto GroupA90183$23224%
131Gillman Cos.A9061$22647%
132Nouri/shaver Automotive GroupA90142$18746%
133Ed Voyles Automotive GroupA9082$1,06329%
134Van Horn Automotive GroupA90154$45146%
135Dream Motor GroupA9095$84320%
136Apple Used AutosA9071$37549%
137Classic Auto GroupA90112$61117%
138Greenway AutomotiveB89307$1,26626%
139RML AutomotiveB89247$49247%
140Kahlig Auto GroupB89171$37630%
141Crown Automotive GroupB89193$1,44714%
142Puente Hills Auto CenterB8991$13939%
143Future Automotive GroupB89121$16044%
144Titus-will Automotive GroupB89101$20151%
145Jimclick Automative TeamB89111$60054%
146McDonald Auto GroupB89111$83238%
147Mike Maroone AutomotiveB8972$85033%
148Gerald Jones Auto GroupB8972$59738%
149Capital Automotive GroupB88342$86551%
150Alm CarsB88102$1,19635%
151Kunes Auto GroupB88274$55432%
152Bob Loquercio Auto GroupB88122$40843%
153Krause Auto GroupB87315$1,20225%
154Earnhardt Auto CentersB87150$62255%
155Fiesta Auto GroupB87112$40338%
156Fred Beans Automotive GroupB86312$50971%
157Anderson Automotive GroupB86193$74251%
158Price Family DealershipsB86141$32922%
159Walser Automotive GroupB86252$52756%
160California Car OnlineB86171$36625%
161Ron Marhofer Auto FamilyB8661$42561%
162Andy Mohr AutomotiveB86132$30964%
163Jenkins Auto GroupB85211$1,83812%
164Southern Auto GroupB85152$95862%
165Open Road Auto GroupB85152$1,15716%
166Niello CompanyB85111$9149%
167Casa Auto GroupB85113$45252%
168Clay Cooley Auto GroupB84261$43348%
169Cardinale Automotive GroupB84253$33553%
170Envision MotorsB84131$16866%
171Berge Auto GroupB8471$86545%
172HGregB8393$1,31227%
173Ancira EnterprisesB82131$22985%
174Grieco Automotive GroupB82155$1,38523%
175Chapman Automotive GroupB81324$72269%
176Valley Auto GroupB81112$85658%
177Courtesy Automotive GroupB8192$70868%
178Oremor Automotive GroupB80192$55719%
179Zt Motors GroupC79154$1,25861%
180Knight Automotive GroupC7951$29559%
181Mills Automotive GroupC78287$88578%
182Indigo Auto GroupC75215$48865%
183Principle AutoC7582$63847%
184Shottenkirk Automotive GroupC74237$78375%
185Demontrond Auto Group’sC72101$83159%
186Dolan Auto GroupC7271$93288%
187Morgan Auto GroupC71721$2,01926%

Rankings are generated from the CarEdge Dealer Transparency Index, a public methodology that scores dealers on verified out-the-door quotes, not Google star ratings or paid placements. CarEdge refreshes the rankings daily as new out-the-door quotes come in.

Share

Sponsored by Insurify

Are you overpaying for car insurance?

Compare rates from top carriers in under 5 minutes. CarEdge users save an average of $996/year on auto insurance.

*Disclosure: CarEdge may earn a commission when you compare insurance quotes through our partner, Insurify. This does not influence our editorial content.*

Free Resource

Get our free car buying cheat sheets & guides

7 PDFs to help you negotiate smarter and spend less at the dealership.

Get FREE Cheat Sheets

Stay on top of car news

No spam, only useful & relevant information and recommendations.

By signing up, you agree to CarEdge's Privacy Policy and Terms and Conditions.

Related Guides