Pricing Transparency
Matthews Buys Cars did not provide pricing by email or text.
4 requests in the past year via text and email. They replied — but never sent a price.
We’ve asked Matthews Buys Cars 4 times in the past year, since April 2026, for an out-the-door price. They replied, but never put a number in writing, not over text and not over email. To get a price you have to call them or visit in person.
Outreach record — 2 via SMS, 2 via email in the past year · Vestal, NY
First contact Apr 29, 2026 · Most recent Aug 7, 2026
Are you this dealer and provide out-the-door pricing in writing? Request a review.
4 requests in the past year for an out-the-door price. Still no written quote.
Every outreach we sent, by channel and by date. They replied — but never sent an OTD, not by email, not by text.
4 of 4 requests explicitly requested an out-the-door price.
Each attempt was a request for the out-the-door price on a real vehicle in their inventory. Per-channel attempts are spaced at least 7 days apart, and total outreach is capped at quarterly limits to avoid harassment.
How this compares
89.9% of GMC dealers in New York respond within 24 hours. Matthews Buys Cars replied too — but 195 days on, still hasn’t put a price in writing.
Based on 889 GMC dealers contacted in New York. Median response time among responders: 1.1 hours.
Why this matters
A written OTD price is a number you can hold a dealer to. Pricing only given by phone or in person changes when you walk in — that’s the whole point of refusing to put it in writing. Dealers who won’t quote OTD over text or email are choosing to keep the final price negotiable until you’re sitting at their desk.
Current Inventory
View all 276 vehicles →$33,250
Median Price
24
Median Days Listed
42
Added This Week
Days on Market
How long vehicles have been listed. Older stock means more room to negotiate.
Nearby Rated Dealers
These dealers near Vestal have transparency scores based on verified pricing data.