Dealer Group

Competition Auto Group

Competition Auto Group runs 6 locations in 1 state and earns a CarEdge transparency grade of A (96/100) from 16 verified out-the-door quotes in the past year.

Average dealer fees
$240
Quoted add-ons
None in quotes from the past year

Verified quotes since 2026

BMWGenesisMercedes-BenzSubaru
A96 / 100
Group transparency scoreBased on 5 graded locations1 ungraded location

Score Breakdown

Fee Transparency (30%)92/100
Add-on Behavior (30%)100/100
Price Accuracy (30%)100/100
Data Quality (10%)85/100
Read the methodology →

Grade Distribution

Across 5 locations graded in the past year

A
5
B
0
C
0
D
0
F
0

100% of locations earned a B or better. No location received an F.

Key Insights

Transparency Score

Scores 96/100, 3.7 points above the national average of 92/100.

Quoted add-ons

None of the quotes from the past year include a quoted add-on. National average: 19%.

Advertised price

100% of past-year quotes we could check against the website matched the advertised price (national average: 59%).

Dealer fees

Stores charged $240 in dealer fees on average over the past year. National average: $613.

All locations

Showing 6 of 6

Work at one of these locations? Claim its page for free. Each location is claimed on its own.

DealerLocationGradeScoreQuotes (past year)BrandDealer FeesQuoted Add-onsDealer page
Mercedes-Benz of SmithtownSaint James, NY
A
1001Mercedes-BenzNot shownNoneClaimed
Competition Subaru of SmithtownSaint James, NY
A
998Subaru$177NoneClaimed
Competition BMW of SmithtownSaint James, NY
A
973BMW$177None
Genesis of SmithtownSaint James, NY
A
943Genesis$175NoneClaimed
Competition Auto GroupSaint James, NY
A
941BMW$199None
Mercedes-Benz of HuntingtonHuntington, NYNot yetrated—————

Group locations

6 locations across New York

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Competition Auto Group a good place to buy a car?

Yes, by CarEdge's measure. Competition Auto Group earns CarEdge transparency grade A (96/100) across 16 verified out-the-door quotes from the past year at 5 stores, graded 5 A. 100% of its graded stores earn an A or B. Grades vary by store, so check the specific location before you buy.

What do reviews say about Competition Auto Group?

CarEdge reviews Competition Auto Group on 16 verified out-the-door quotes from the past year, not star ratings. Competition Auto Group earns CarEdge transparency grade A (96/100) across 16 verified out-the-door quotes from the past year at 5 stores, graded 5 A. No quoted add-ons show up in those quotes, and 100% of the quotes we could check against the website matched the advertised price.

What fees do Competition Auto Group dealerships charge?

Its stores average $240 in dealer fees across 16 verified out-the-door quotes from the past year.

Do Competition Auto Group dealerships add dealer add-ons?

CarEdge's verified quotes from the past year show no quoted add-ons on Competition Auto Group quotes. Ask any store for an itemized out-the-door quote with all dealer add-ons removed before you visit.

Which Competition Auto Group dealership is the best?

Competition Subaru of Smithtown in Saint James, NY is Competition Auto Group's highest-graded store on the CarEdge Dealer Transparency Index: grade A (99/100) from 8 verified out-the-door quotes in the past year.

Do Competition Auto Group advertised prices include all required charges?

On 100% of the past-year quotes we could check against the website, the out-the-door price before taxes and government fees matched the store's advertised price. Check each store's page for its own result.