Dealer Group
Competition Auto Group
Competition Auto Group runs 6 locations in 1 state and earns a CarEdge transparency grade of B (83/100) from 15 verified out-the-door quotes.
- Average doc fee
- $175
- Dealer add-ons
- None in verified quotes
- Top-graded store
- Genesis of Smithtown (A)
Verified quotes since 2025
Score Breakdown
Grade Distribution
Across 5 rated locations
60% of locations earned a B or better. No location received an F.
Key Insights
Transparency Score
Scores 83/100, 3.3 points below the national average of 86.3/100.
Add-on Frequency
0% of transactions include an add-on, 17% less often than the national average of 17%.
Listing-to-OTD Gap
Prices run -0.6% above listing on average, better than the national average of 90.7%.
Top performers in this group
Locations with D or below: 2 — Mercedes-Benz of Smithtown, Competition Auto Group
All locations
| Dealer | Location | Grade | Score | Quotes | Brand | Doc Fee | Add-on Rate |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Genesis of Smithtown | Saint James, NY | A | 100 | 4 | Genesis | $175 | 0% |
| Competition Subaru of Smithtown | Saint James, NY | A | 99 | 7 | Subaru | $175 | 0% |
| Competition BMW of Smithtown | Saint James, NY | A | 95 | 2 | BMW | $175 | 0% |
| Mercedes-Benz of Smithtown | Saint James, NY | D | 60 | 1 | Mercedes | — | 0% |
| Competition Auto Group | Saint James, NY | D | 60 | 1 | — | — | 0% |
| Mercedes-Benz of Huntington | Huntington, NY | Not yetrated | — | — | — | — | — |
Group locations
6 locations across New York
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Competition Auto Group a good place to buy a car?
Yes, by CarEdge's measure. Competition Auto Group earns CarEdge transparency grade B (83/100) across 15 verified out-the-door quotes from 5 stores, graded 3 A, 2 D. 60% of its graded stores earn an A or B. Grades vary by store, so check the specific location before you buy.
What do reviews say about Competition Auto Group?
CarEdge reviews Competition Auto Group on 15 verified out-the-door quotes, not star ratings. Competition Auto Group earns CarEdge transparency grade B (83/100) across 15 verified out-the-door quotes from 5 stores, graded 3 A, 2 D. Across those quotes its stores show no dealer add-ons in verified quotes.
What is the doc fee at Competition Auto Group dealerships?
Its stores average a $175 doc fee across 15 verified out-the-door quotes.
Do Competition Auto Group dealerships add dealer add-ons?
CarEdge's verified quotes from Competition Auto Group stores show no dealer add-ons in verified quotes. Ask any store for an itemized out-the-door quote with all dealer add-ons removed before you visit.
Which Competition Auto Group dealership is the best?
Genesis of Smithtown in Saint James, NY is Competition Auto Group's highest-graded store on the CarEdge Dealer Transparency Index: grade A (100/100) from 4 verified out-the-door quotes.