2026 Subaru Forester Premium prices in New York
From 15 real out-the-door quotes that 7 dealers sent , Jul to Oct 2026. Not listing prices. Not estimates.
Great deal
$1,900off MSRP
or more, from the dealer
5.1% off the typical $36,600 MSRP
Few of these quotes list rebates on their own line, so these figures may include manufacturer rebates.
- Fair deal
- $1,500 off
- 4.0% off MSRP, typical
- High price
- At MSRP
- Or above
Hover a dot to see that dealer's written quote. Click to keep it open.Every quote here was sent to CarEdge by a dealer. Watch CarEdge's AI negotiate live
New York dealers and their quotes
15 quotes from 7 New York dealers. Brewster Subaru gave the biggest discount: $1,400 off at its typical quote, across 4 quotes.
- ASubaru White PlainsElmsford
- AStar SubaruQueens
- AMid-Hudson SubaruWappingers Falls
- AFive Star SubaruOneonta
Dealers with one quote are listed last.
For sale now in New York
Advertised prices, set against what dealers quoted in writing for the same trim and MSRP over the last year. Advertised prices often count rebates not every buyer qualifies for.
2026 Subaru Forester prices by trim in New York
The window sticker, what dealers take off it, and what they quote, from written out-the-door quotes.
| Trim | Typical MSRP | Dealer discount | Selling price | Out the door | Quotes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Premium | $36,600 | $1,500 off | $35,300 | $38,500 | 15 |
| Sport | $39,600 | At MSRP | $39,100 | $42,800 | 8 |
| Touring | $42,100 | $1,800 off | $40,800 | $44,800 | 11 |
Typical means the median quote. Dealer discount is less any add-ons or extra fees the dealer added. Few of these quotes list rebates on their own line, so it may include them. Out the door includes tax, title and fees, which depend on where the buyer registers.
All 15 quotesEach one a written out-the-door quote a dealer sent a CarEdge shopper, with the dealer's document.
| Date | Dealer | Vehicle | MSRP | Dealer discount | Rebates | Selling price | Out the door | Document |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Oct 7, 2026 | ABrewster SubaruBrewster, NY | 2026 Premium | $37,469 | $1,806 off | – | $35,663 | $38,500 | See quote |
| Oct 7, 2026 | ABrewster SubaruBrewster, NY | 2026 Premium | $35,866 | $1,101 off | – | $34,566 | $37,545 | See quote |
| Oct 5, 2026 | AMid-Hudson SubaruWappingers Falls, NY | 2026 Premium | $37,391 | $1,636 off | – | $35,755 | $38,872 | See quote |
| Oct 3, 2026 | ABrewster SubaruBrewster, NY | 2026 Premium | $37,600 | $1,600 off | – | $36,000 | $38,859 | See quote |
| Oct 3, 2026 | ABrewster SubaruBrewster, NY | 2026 Premium | $36,600 | $199 over MSRP | – | $36,600 | $39,708 | See quote |
| Sep 5, 2026 | ARye SubaruRye, NY | 2026 Premium | $35,517 | $2,474 off | – | $32,519 | $36,500 | See quote |
| Sep 5, 2026 | ARye SubaruRye, NY | 2026 Premium | $35,517 | $1,976 off | – | $33,017 | $37,040 | See quote |
| Sep 4, 2026 | ANorth Coast SubaruGlen Cove, NY | 2026 Premium | $35,300 | At MSRP | – | $35,300 | $38,468 | See quote |
| Sep 3, 2026 | ANorth Coast SubaruGlen Cove, NY | 2026 Premium | $37,812 | $1,500 off | – | $36,312 | $39,761 | See quote |
| Sep 3, 2026 | ASubaru White PlainsElmsford, NY | 2026 Premium | $37,988 | $3,812 off | – | $34,176 | $37,500 | See quote |
| Sep 1, 2026 | ANorth Coast SubaruGlen Cove, NY | 2026 Premium | $37,812 | At MSRP | – | $37,812 | $41,386 | See quote |
| Aug 31, 2026 | ARye SubaruRye, NY | 2026 Premium | $34,700 | At MSRP | – | $34,700 | $38,086 | See quote |
| Aug 31, 2026 | ARye SubaruRye, NY | 2026 Premium | $35,083 | At MSRP | – | $35,083 | $38,469 | See quote |
| Aug 30, 2026 | AStar SubaruQueens, NY | 2026 Premium | $37,356 | $2,000 off | – | $35,356 | $38,735 | See quote |
| Jul 31, 2026 | AFive Star SubaruOneonta, NY | 2026 Premium | $33,460 | $332 over MSRP | – | $33,460 | $36,469 | See quote |
New Subaru Forester discounts by city and state
The dealer discount each place's own page leads with: before rebates, less any add-ons, other dealer fees and doc fee above the state's typical one. A place marked “may include rebates” has too few quotes that list rebates on their own line to leave them out. Places with too few quotes of their own are left out.
| Place | Aim for | Typical | Doc fee | Quotes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Houston, TXmay include rebates | $3,800 off | $3,600 off | $225 | 6 |
| Dallas, TXmay include rebates | $4,400 off | $4,100 off | $225 | 8 |
| Austin, TXmay include rebates | $2,900 off | $2,300 off | $225 | 10 |
| Los Angeles, CAmay include rebates | $3,800 off | $3,000 off | $85 | 37 |
| San Francisco, CAmay include rebates | $1,100 off | At MSRP | $85 | 15 |
| Sacramento, CAmay include rebates | $1,100 off | $700 off | $85 | 6 |
| Phoenix, AZmay include rebates | $3,100 off | $2,500 off | $549 | 15 |
| Denver, COmay include rebates | $3,900 off | $3,300 off | $694 | 13 |
| Miami, FLmay include rebates | $4,600 off | $3,800 off | $999 | 8 |
| Orlando, FLmay include rebates | $4,400 off | $3,800 off | $1,199 | 10 |
| Tampa, FLmay include rebates | $4,400 off | $3,100 off | $1,195 | 16 |
| Washington, DCmay include rebates | $5,100 off | $3,600 off | $995 | 57 |
| Baltimore, MDmay include rebates | $5,100 off | $3,500 off | $995 | 55 |
| Philadelphia, PAmay include rebates | $3,900 off | $3,400 off | $699 | 38 |
| New York, NYmay include rebates | $3,400 off | $2,000 off | $699 | 74 |
| Boston, MAmay include rebates | $4,900 off | $3,100 off | $619 | 15 |
| Chicago, ILmay include rebates | $3,400 off | $1,900 off | $378 | 16 |
| Place | Aim for | Typical | Doc fee | Quotes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Alabamamay include rebates | $4,200 off | $3,200 off | $899 | 11 |
| Arizonamay include rebates | $3,100 off | $2,500 off | $549 | 20 |
| Californiamay include rebates | $3,400 off | $1,900 off | $85 | 60 |
| Coloradomay include rebates | $3,600 off | $2,500 off | $694 | 17 |
| Connecticutmay include rebates | $2,600 off | $1,900 off | $795 | 16 |
| Floridamay include rebates | $4,400 off | $2,800 off | $999 | 38 |
| Illinoismay include rebates | $4,000 off | $2,700 off | $378 | 17 |
| Indianamay include rebates | $2,300 off | $2,100 off | $249 | 6 |
| Kentuckymay include rebates | $3,300 off | $3,100 off | $699 | 6 |
| Marylandmay include rebates | $5,300 off | $2,900 off | $799 | 25 |
| Massachusettsmay include rebates | $4,900 off | $4,100 off | $639 | 16 |
| Michiganmay include rebates | $1,500 off | $200 off | $280 | 6 |
| New Jerseymay include rebates | $3,900 off | $3,300 off | $699 | 34 |
| New Yorkmay include rebates | $1,800 off | $1,200 off | $175 | 35 |
| North Carolinamay include rebates | $2,800 off | $2,200 off | $799 | 6 |
| Ohiomay include rebates | $3,700 off | $3,500 off | $398 | 11 |
| Pennsylvaniamay include rebates | $3,700 off | $3,100 off | $490 | 11 |
| Tennesseemay include rebates | $4,400 off | $3,400 off | $749 | 13 |
| Texasmay include rebates | $4,200 off | $3,200 off | $225 | 27 |
| Virginiamay include rebates | $5,100 off | $4,000 off | $998 | 33 |
| Wisconsinmay include rebates | $3,100 off | $2,200 off | $399 | 11 |
Subaru Forester price questions in New York
What should I pay for a new Subaru Forester in New York?
Aim for 4.7% below MSRP on a new 2026 Subaru Forester in New York. The typical written quote is 3.6% below MSRP. This compares the selling price after any rebates with MSRP. Based on itemized out-the-door quotes Subaru dealers sent CarEdge shoppers.
How much of a dealer discount should I ask for on a new Subaru Forester in New York?
Aim for a dealer discount of $1,800 off MSRP or more on a new 2026 Subaru Forester in New York, after any add-ons, extra dealer fees or doc fee above the state's typical one. The typical dealer discount is $1,200 off. Few of these quotes list rebates on their own line, so the figure may include manufacturer incentives. Rebates and incentives vary by region, change over time, and some have qualification rules, and some quotes fold them into the discount.
Which dealers have the best Subaru Forester deals in New York?
Of the dealers with at least 2 written quotes on a new 2026 Subaru Forester in New York, Mid-Hudson Subaru quotes the deepest typical dealer discount: $2,200 off across 3 quotes. Next are Romano Subaru ($1,900 off) and Zappone Subaru Norwich ($1,300 off). Few of these quotes list rebates on their own line, so these figures may include manufacturer rebates.
What is a good price for a used Subaru Forester in New York?
Dealers quote a used 2024 Subaru Forester in the US at $25,600 to $29,900 before tax and fees, with a typical quote of $27,000. Too few quotes matched the exact pick, so CarEdge borrowed quotes from across the US. Mileage moves used prices, so compare vehicles with similar miles.
When are Forester discounts deepest?
Dealers quoted the deepest discounts on a new Subaru Forester in New York in February 2026: 8.7% below MSRP at the median. In October 2026 the median quote is 4.2% below MSRP. This compares the selling price after any rebates with MSRP.
Which Forester trim gets the biggest discount?
The Forester Touring gets the deepest discounts in New York: 4.2% below MSRP at the median quote. The Sport gets the least, at MSRP. This compares the selling price after any rebates with MSRP.
What do Subaru dealers add on to the Forester?
9% of new Forester quotes in New York include dealer add-ons, at a median of $390 when they do.
What doc fee do Subaru dealers charge?
The median doc fee on a new Forester quote in New York is $175. Half of quotes fall between $175 and $286.
What does out the door add to the Forester?
Out the door adds about $3,300 to the selling price of a new 2026 Subaru Forester in New York, mostly tax. The median out-the-door total across these quotes is $41,900.