Best Car Dealers Near Saint James, NY

As of November 2026, CarEdge grades 14 of 19 car dealers near Saint James, NY from 37 quotes from the past year. The median rated dealer here charges $175 in total dealer fees.

Data updated Nov 13, 2026 · How we score dealers

Based on 14 dealers with quotes from the past year.

$175
Median Dealer Fees
NY median: $175
95%
No Quoted Add-ons
93/100
Avg Score
37
Quotes, Past Year

Browse Dealers by Brand in Saint James

All Car Dealers Near Saint James

Empire Volvo Cars Smithtown

Saint James, NY · 1 quote, past yearLimited data

$175dealer feesNo quoted add-ons
A
100/100
Highly transparent
See 1 verified quote →

Smithtown Volkswagen

Saint James, NY · 1 quote, past yearLimited data

$175dealer feesNo quoted add-ons
A
100/100
Highly transparent
See 1 verified quote →

Mercedes-Benz of Smithtown

Saint James, NY · 1 quote, past yearLimited data

Dealer fees not shownNo quoted add-ons
A
100/100
Highly transparent
See 1 verified quote →

Chevrolet of Smithtown

Saint James, NY · 2 quotes, past yearLimited data

$88dealer feesNo quoted add-ons
A
99/100
Highly transparent
See 2 verified quotes →

Competition Subaru of Smithtown

Saint James, NY · 8 quotes, past year

$177dealer feesNo quoted add-ons
A
99/100
Highly transparent
See 8 verified quotes →

Lexus of Smithtown

Saint James, NY · 3 quotes, past year

$175dealer feesNo quoted add-ons
A
98/100
Highly transparent
See 3 verified quotes →

Smith Haven Mazda

Saint James, NY · 3 quotes, past year

$88dealer fees33%quoted add-ons
A
97/100
Highly transparent
See 3 verified quotes →

Competition BMW of Smithtown

Saint James, NY · 3 quotes, past year

$177dealer feesNo quoted add-ons
A
97/100
Highly transparent
See 3 verified quotes →

Smithtown Kia

Saint James, NY · 7 quotes, past year

$175dealer feesNo quoted add-ons
A
96/100
Highly transparent
See 7 verified quotes →

Genesis of Smithtown

Saint James, NY · 3 quotes, past year

$175dealer feesNo quoted add-ons
A
94/100
Highly transparent
See 3 verified quotes →

Competition Auto Group

Saint James, NY · 1 quote, past yearLimited data

$199dealer feesNo quoted add-ons
A
94/100
Highly transparent
See 1 verified quote →

Lincoln of Smithtown

Saint James, NY · 1 quote, past yearLimited data

$175dealer fees100%quoted add-ons
B
82/100
Above average
See 1 verified quote →

Advantage Acura

Saint James, NY · 2 quotes, past yearLimited data

$870dealer feesNo quoted add-ons
C
79/100
Average
See 2 verified quotes →

Ford of Smithtown

Saint James, NY · 1 quote, past yearLimited data

$895dealer feesNo quoted add-ons
C
78/100
Average
See 1 verified quote →

Advantage Honda

Saint James, NYNo Pricing Provided

F
0/100
Buyer beware

Audi of Smithtown

Saint James, NY

Audi
—
Not rated

Buyonline.Autos

Saint James, NY

—
Not rated

Carmax Smithtown

Saint James, NY

—
Not rated

Certified Headquarters

Saint James, NY

—
Not rated

Tips for Buying a Car in NY

  • Know the dealer fees: The median NY dealer charges $175 in total dealer fees. If a dealer charges significantly more, ask which fees they will drop.
  • Good news on add-ons: 95% of quotes from the past year near Saint James have no quoted add-ons.
  • Get multiple quotes: Request OTD quotes from at least 3 dealers to compare total prices, not just sticker prices.
  • Check transparency scores: Dealers with scores above 80 typically have fair dealer fees, few quoted add-ons and website prices that match the quote.

Car Dealers Near Saint James FAQ

What is the best car dealer near Saint James, NY?

Competition Subaru of Smithtown (Saint James, NY) is the highest-graded dealer near Saint James on the CarEdge Dealer Transparency Index — A grade, 99/100, based on 8 quotes from the past year.

What do dealers near Saint James charge in dealer fees?

As of November 2026, the median rated dealer near Saint James, NY charges $175 in total dealer fees, the doc fee plus every other fee the dealer adds, compared with a NY median of $175, based on 37 quotes from the past year.

How does CarEdge rank dealers near Saint James?

Each dealer is scored 0-100 from verified out-the-door quotes from the past year, with the newest counting most — fee transparency (30%, total dealer fees compared with the NY median), add-on behavior (30%), price accuracy (30%), and data quality (10%) — and graded A-F. Rankings update as new quotes near Saint James are verified.